The Slaughterhouse Cases: Regulation, Reconstruction, and the Fourteenth Amendment (Landmark Law Cases & American Society) Book PDF, ePub eBook

Join our eBook service for unlimited books & audiobooks. Get a free 7 day subscription! ↓↓↓↓↓


Book Descriptions:
The Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution, ratified in 1868, sought to protect the rights of the newly freed slaves; but its first important test did not arise until five years later. When it did, it centered on a vitriolic dispute among the white butchers of mid-Reconstruction New Orleans.

The rough-and-tumble world of nineteenth-century New Orleans was a sanitation nightmare, with the city's many slaughterhouses dumping animal remains into neighboring backwaters. When Louisiana finally authorized a monopoly slaughterhouse to bring about sanitation reform, many butchers felt disenfranchised from their livelihoods. Framing their case as an infringement of fundamental rights protected by the new amendment, they flooded the lower courts with nearly 300 suits. The surviving cases that reached the U.S. Supreme Court pitted the butchers' right-to-labor against the state's "police power" to regulate public health. The result was a controversial and long-debated decision that for the first time addressed the meaning and import of the Fourteenth Amendment.

Speaking for the slim majority in the Court's 5-4 decision, Justice Samuel F. Miller upheld the state's actions as a fair use of its "police power." Of much greater import, however, was Miller's finding that the Fourteenth Amendment was intended exclusively as a means of protecting and redressing the suffering of former slaves. The result was a very restricted interpretation of the "privileges and immunities," "due process," and "equal protection" clauses of the new amendment. Accustomed to a very limited federal presence in the states, the Court refused to allow the broad terms of a single amendment to alter the existing balance of power between the states and the federal government.

In striking contrast, the minority, represented most notably by Justice Stephen Field, claimed that the Fourteenth Amendment had been intended to apply to all Americans, not just former slaves. In particular, the minority contended, it guaranteed the New Orleans butchers a right to equal treatment in the exercise of the police power. The position of the dissenters foreshadowed an aggressive use of the Court's power in the protection of fundamental rights in the future.

In The Slaughterhouse Cases, Labb and Lurie take a much needed look at a landmark decision that has been far more cited than closely studied. Engagingly written and insightfully argued, the book provides the most complete analysis yet of this controversial Supreme Court decision, fills a major gap in American history, law, and politics, and sets the standard for all future discussions on the subject.

The Slaughterhouse Cases: Regulation, Reconstruction, and the Fourteenth Amendment (Landmark Law Cases & American Society) by Ronald M. Labbe, Jonathan Lurie

From reader reviews:

Darlene Trevino:

Inside other case, little persons like to read book The Slaughterhouse Cases: Regulation, Reconstruction, and the Fourteenth Amendment (Landmark Law Cases & American Society). You can choose the best book if you love reading a book. Provided that we know about how is important any book The Slaughterhouse Cases: Regulation, Reconstruction, and the Fourteenth Amendment (Landmark Law Cases & American Society). You can add know-how and of course you can around the world with a book. Absolutely right, because from book you can realize everything! From your country until foreign or abroad you will find yourself known. About simple factor until wonderful thing you may know that. In this era, we are able to open a book or even searching by internet device. It is called e-book. You can utilize it when you feel uninterested to go to the library. Let's go through.

James Kyles:

You may spend your free time you just read this book this book. This The Slaughterhouse Cases: Regulation, Reconstruction, and the Fourteenth Amendment (Landmark Law Cases & American Society) is simple to develop you can read it in the park, in the beach, train and also soon. If you did not get much space to bring the actual printed book, you can buy the particular e-book. It is make you quicker to read it. You can save the particular book in your smart phone. And so there are a lot of benefits that you will get when you buy this book.

Belinda Tenney:

As a pupil exactly feel bored to reading. If their teacher questioned them to go to the library or even make summary for some guide, they are complained. Just little students that has reading's soul or real their interest. They just do what the trainer want, like asked to the library. They go to generally there but nothing reading critically. Any students feel that reading through is not important, boring and also can't see colorful pics on there. Yeah, it is to become complicated. Book is very important to suit your needs. As we know that on this age, many ways to get whatever we want. Likewise word says, many ways to reach Chinese's country. So , this The Slaughterhouse Cases: Regulation, Reconstruction, and the Fourteenth Amendment (Landmark Law Cases & American Society) can make you truly feel more interested to read.

Melissa Sands:

Guide is one of source of understanding. We can add our know-how from it. Not only for students and also native or citizen have to have book to know the upgrade information of year for you to year. As we know those textbooks have many advantages. Beside we add our knowledge, also can bring us to around the world. With the book The Slaughterhouse Cases: Regulation, Reconstruction, and the Fourteenth Amendment (Landmark Law Cases & American Society) we can consider more advantage. Don't you to be creative people? To be creative person must want to read a book. Just simply choose the best book that suitable with your aim. Don't always be doubt to change your life by this book The Slaughterhouse Cases: Regulation, Reconstruction, and the Fourteenth Amendment (Landmark Law Cases & American Society). You can more attractive than now.